Students, faculty try to sever PC’s relationship with Renaissance Hotel


Deprecated: Function get_magic_quotes_gpc() is deprecated in /hermes/bosnacweb08/bosnacweb08bf/b1577/ipg.rifuturecom/RIFutureNew/wp-includes/formatting.php on line 4387

Deprecated: Function get_magic_quotes_gpc() is deprecated in /hermes/bosnacweb08/bosnacweb08bf/b1577/ipg.rifuturecom/RIFutureNew/wp-includes/formatting.php on line 4387
Members of Local 217 gather outside the Renaissance Hotel for an Informational Picket.
Members of Local 217 gather outside the Renaissance Hotel for an Informational Picket.

Providence College students and faculty plan to leaflet campus tomorrow to draw attention to the school’s continued relationship with the Renaissance Hotel, one of the downtown hotels engaged in a bitter labor dispute with employees trying to unionize and win better wages.

“Consistent with our social values, the group wants PC to refrain from doing business with the Renaissance Hotel until management grants workers a fair process to decide on unionization,” said a press release from PC sociology professor Cedric de Leon.  “This means removing the Renaissance from the list of discounted hotels advertised on the PC website for Reunion Weekend, May 29-31, and telling alums why.”

de Leon has led an effort at the Providence College to stop doing business with the hotel because owner The Procaccianti Group “has a track record of mistreating Renaissance workers in a manner inconsistent with Catholic social teaching,” said the press release. “In 2007, U.S. Catholic Bishops wrote, ‘Catholic social teaching supports the right of workers to choose whether to organize, join a union, and bargain collectively, and to exercise these rights without reprisal.'”

In a subsequent interview, de Leon said, “We’re going to turn up the heat on the administration.” It’s unjust that Providence College boycotts sweatshop labor abroad but endorses poor labor relations in its host city, he said. “We won’t sell sweat shop clothing but the Renaissance Hotel is, for some reason sacred.”

Last year more than 200 faculty and students signed a letter expressing their desire to not do business with the Renaissance Hotel, but school administration declined to act upon the request, de Leon said.

Not only will the group leaflet campus on Wednesday, but they also plan on asking Rev. Gustavo Gutiérrez, a liberation theologist, about PC’s support of a hotel mired in a labor dispute with employees when he visits campus on Monday to receive an honorary degree.

A Providence College press release describes Gutiérrez: “A native of Peru, he is best known for his 1971 book, A Theology of Liberation: History, Politics, and Salvation, which advocated for supporting the poor in protests against poverty and in attempts to be liberated from exploitation.”  The Economist describes liberation theology as “an ideological movement that emerged in Latin America in the 1970s and sought to combine Catholicism with revolutionary socialism.”

Here’s the full press release from de Leon:

What: Leafleting urging Providence College (PC) to boycott the Renaissance Hotel

Who: Concerned students and faculty at PC

When: Wednesday, April 22, 12:30pm

Where: Starts at Harkins Hall (Main Entrance)

Why: Anti-worker practices by Renaissance Hotel

On Wednesday, April 22 at 12:30pm, students and faculty at Providence College will leaflet four major stops on the visitor tour circuit: Harkins Hall (the main administration building), Phillips Memorial Library, Raymond Hall (the main dining hall), and Slavin (the student center).

PC continues to do business with the Renaissance Hotel even though the hotel’s owner, The Procaccianti Group (TPG), has a track record of mistreating Renaissance workers in a manner inconsistent with Catholic social teaching. In 2007, U.S. Catholic Bishops wrote, “Catholic social teaching supports the right of workers to choose whether to organize, join a union, and bargain collectively, and to exercise these rights without reprisal.”

TPG, however, has been the subject of two federal enforcement actions at the Renaissance in the past two years: first, by the Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA), for unsafe working conditions; and second, by the National Labor Relations Board, for workplace intimidation.

On March 26, 2013, a majority of Renaissance workers presented the hotel manager with a petition requesting a fair process to decide on unionization. Instead of granting workers a fair process, TPG has responded with an aggressive and illegal anti-union campaign, involving what the federal government itself has called “interrogating employees about their union activities.”

Despite all this, the administration has resisted joining the boycott. When Renaissance workers came to PC, asking to suspend business with the hotel, the administration had them escorted off campus. Later, when PC students and faculty presented administration with 200+ signatures urging the College to boycott the hotel, they said there was “no compelling interest for Providence College to advise the families of our students and our alumni to avoid using the hotel.”

Consistent with our social values, the group wants PC to refrain from doing business with the Renaissance Hotel until management grants workers a fair process to decide on unionization. This means removing the Renaissance from the list of discounted hotels advertised on the PC website for Reunion Weekend, May 29-31, and telling alums why. Brown University and other organizations have already taken this principled step.

The group is also asking those concerned to email President Fr. Brian Shanley at bshanley@providence.edu to say that there are plenty of Providence hotels for our alumni to choose from and that the Renaissance should not be one of them.

 

As state steps in, hotel workers fight for local control


Deprecated: Function get_magic_quotes_gpc() is deprecated in /hermes/bosnacweb08/bosnacweb08bf/b1577/ipg.rifuturecom/RIFutureNew/wp-includes/formatting.php on line 4387

Deprecated: Function get_magic_quotes_gpc() is deprecated in /hermes/bosnacweb08/bosnacweb08bf/b1577/ipg.rifuturecom/RIFutureNew/wp-includes/formatting.php on line 4387

DSC_8951More than 125 people turned out a rally at the State House against the General Assembly’s proposed state ban on cities and municipalities setting their own minimum wage standards. Citizens, workers and elected officials raised their collective voices to tell House Leadership that this legislative power grab will not be welcome in Rhode Island.

Dave Jamieson, at the Huffington Post, has an alarming piece about how Rhode Island is the only state with a supposedly Democratically controlled legislature considering such a ban, saying, “State Democrats in Rhode Island have apparently taken a page from the Republican playbook, moving to preemptively block cities and counties from establishing their own local minimum wages.”

The proposed law has been snuck into the state budget, and may be approved as early as Thursday night by the House before it moves onto the Senate. Representative Gallison, who has fronted this ALEC-style bill, claims to want to protect business competitiveness, but in truth this bill is calculated to do just one thing: separate an entire set of people from their ability to access government.

DSC_8545
Two hotel workers outside the State House before the rally.

DSC_8615

DSC_8643

DSC_8721
Providence City Councillor Carmen Castillo

DSC_8766

DSC_8771

DSC_8775

DSC_8798
Providence City Councillor Luis Aponte

DSC_8823

DSC_8847
Providence City Councillor Kevin Jackson
DSC_8876
A worried Republican looks on, but “Democrats” have his back.
DSC_8901
Central Falls City Councillor Shelby Maldonado
DSC_8959
State Representative Grace Dias
DSC_8976
State Representative Joseph Almeida

DSC_9030

DSC_9040
Krystle Martin

DSC_9049

DSC_9094
Jack Temple, National Employment Law Project

DSC_9115

DSC_9159

DSC_9171

DSC_9180

DSC_9194
Hotel worker Adrienne Jones

DSC_9241

DSC_9298

DSC_9315

Taveras: prefers state-based minimum wage but open to hotel proposal


Deprecated: Function get_magic_quotes_gpc() is deprecated in /hermes/bosnacweb08/bosnacweb08bf/b1577/ipg.rifuturecom/RIFutureNew/wp-includes/formatting.php on line 4387

Deprecated: Function get_magic_quotes_gpc() is deprecated in /hermes/bosnacweb08/bosnacweb08bf/b1577/ipg.rifuturecom/RIFutureNew/wp-includes/formatting.php on line 4387
Providence Mayor Angel Taveras at Netroots Nation. (Photo by Bob Plain)
Providence Mayor Angel Taveras at Netroots Nation. (Photo by Bob Plain)

Providence Mayor Angel Taveras “believes it is better to raise the wage at the state level but is open to the proposed ordinance before the City Council,” said campaign spokeswoman Dawn Bergantino today.

“The City of Seattle spent months studying the issue before the recent passage of a citywide wage,” she said. “The Mayor believes it is equally important that Providence do an economic impact study to understand what, if any, consequence we may see and to ensure the proposal will help those it is intended to, in the way it is intended to. He wants to make sure that we have an economy that is fair and provides opportunity to everyone.”

The statement comes as the mayor may have to weigh in on a $15 minimum wage for the hotel industry in Providence, as activists have put a proposal before the City Council, and as Rep. Ray Gallison is pushing a bill that would block cities and towns from having higher minimum wages than the state.

Bergantino said Taveras did not ask House Finance Committee Chairman Ray Gallison to put forward a bill that would prevent cities and towns from setting their own minimum wage.

It’s still unclear why Gallison, chairman of the powerful House Finance Committee, proposed the bill as he prepares to lead the budget bill through his committee. House spokesman Larry Berman said he didn’t know what prompted Gallison to support the move, which is usually associated with conservative low wage activists.

DSC_8223Providence City Councilor Carmen Castillo, who is also a hotel housekeeper, took umbrage with Gallison meddling in city politics.

“Representative Gallison’s proposal is an attack on all RI cities and towns,” she said in an email to RI Future. “It will strip us of our power to represent our communities. What power will they try to take from us next?  The right to decide if we should have a casino in our town?  The right to set our own budgets?”

Castillo, who works at the Omni Hotel, added, “I make almost $15 per hour.  I proudly clean 15 hotel rooms a day for Providence tourists – guests from graduations and conventions, tourists on their way to Cape Cod  and business travelers all sleep in clean rooms because of hundreds of women like me.  I was able to buy a house and send my daughters to college.  I eat in my neighborhood restaurants and shop in the bodegas.”

Councilman Sam Zurier said he wasn’t familiar enough with Gallison’s bill to weigh in. But he reiterated what he has written in his constituent newsletter:

“I have an open mind on this issue, and I will attend the hearing looking for answers to several questions, including the following: (1) What is the current wage scale at Providence hotels, including those that have unions?; (2) What is a living wage for Providence?; (3) What are the costs/benefits of (a) a minimum wage at the municipal (rather than state or national) level, and (b) an industry-specific minimum wage?; (4) What ramifications would the ordinance have for other hotel employees, such as those employed in a hotel restaurant or gift shop, and what would be the full impact on room rates and hotel operations?”

Preemptive laws against municipal minimum wages: ALEC idea


Deprecated: Function get_magic_quotes_gpc() is deprecated in /hermes/bosnacweb08/bosnacweb08bf/b1577/ipg.rifuturecom/RIFutureNew/wp-includes/formatting.php on line 4387

Deprecated: Function get_magic_quotes_gpc() is deprecated in /hermes/bosnacweb08/bosnacweb08bf/b1577/ipg.rifuturecom/RIFutureNew/wp-includes/formatting.php on line 4387

alecHouse Finance Committee Chairman Ray Gallison’s new bill to remove local control of minimum wage laws is akin to a corporate-funded effort across the country to suppress living wage protections. The tactic is known as passing “preemption laws” and it’s been tied back to the American Legislative Exchange Council, or ALEC, the right wing bill mill that drafts corporate-friendly legislation for state legislators.

“Business-backed groups that oppose living wages and paid leave have a serious problem on their hands: polls show that they’re popular,” according to (Bill) Moyers and Company in a report on Oklahoma’s new living wage restrictions. “So-called preemption laws provide them with a solution.”

ALEC-sponsored “preemptive laws” are often cited when it comes to paid leave bills (see here, here and here). A 2013 Economic Policy Institute study by Gordon Lafer (The Legislative Attack on American Wages and Labor Standards) says ALEC suggests that legislators from left-leaning states introduce bills that stop minimum wages from being enacted at the municipal level.

“In many states, big cities are more progressive than the state as a whole. As a result, as of 2010, 123 cities or counties had adopted ordinances mandating minimum wages, living wages, or prevailing wages higher than the state standard,” Lafer writes. “To combat such initiatives, ALEC’s minimum-wage repeal bill abolishes any existing local minimum-wage laws in addition to the state statute itself, and forbids localities from enacting wage laws in the future.”

Gallison, a Bristol Democrat, introduced an amendment to the state minimum wage law on Wednesday that would prohibit cities and towns from enacting minimum wage laws. His amendment reads: “No municipality shall establish, mandate, or otherwise require an employer to pay a minimum wage to its employees, other than the state or federal mandated minimum wage, or to apply a state or federal minimum wage law to wages statutorily exempt from a state or federal minimum wage requirement.”

House Spokesman Larry Berman told WPRI’s Dan McGowan the proposal is a reaction to a $15 hotel industry minimum wage before the Providence City Council. Gallison, who isn’t and wasn’t an ALEC member, supports a much smaller increase to the state minimum wage. He did not say why he wants to limit cities and towns from setting their own rate.

Hotel workers, activists ask PVD for $15 minimum wage


Deprecated: Function get_magic_quotes_gpc() is deprecated in /hermes/bosnacweb08/bosnacweb08bf/b1577/ipg.rifuturecom/RIFutureNew/wp-includes/formatting.php on line 4387

Deprecated: Function get_magic_quotes_gpc() is deprecated in /hermes/bosnacweb08/bosnacweb08bf/b1577/ipg.rifuturecom/RIFutureNew/wp-includes/formatting.php on line 4387

Fight for 15 007Reading Rhode Island’s paper of record this morning about the Providence City Council meeting where public testimony was taken on a proposal to raise the minimum wage for hotel workers to $15 would certainly give the false impression that “Dozens of speakers testified before the panel, both for and against the plan.” In truth, 22 people testified for the proposal, and only five people testified against it. Over 200 supporters rallied at City Hall. The measure is overwhelmingly popular, but the ProJo decided to bury the item on the bottom of page five.

That’s too bad, because the successful passage of this proposal would put Providence at the forefront of the battle for a fair and equitable living wage for all people, and the ProJo will be playing catch up when the national media turns its attention here. $15 an hour will change the lives of Providence hotel workers, who barely survive on meager paychecks and government assistance. It will change the lives of their children, opening up opportunities for better education, health care and child care. It will expand local businesses as the new money put into the hands of local workers will be spent locally. It will allow Providence workers the ability to afford to live in Providence.

This is a game changer, and the Providence City Council would show real wisdom in passing this. Establishing this city as a place where workers are treated well and not exploited will be an economic draw, not a detriment. This is an issue of basic human compassion: Nobody should work so hard and make so little. Good people realize this, and want to support the businesses and communities that embody these values.

Those speaking for the hotels spun the same old gloom and doom prognoses concerning higher room rates, loss of competitive pricing, and loss of profits. This from multi-billion dollar corporations that operate hotels all over the world, including places with minimum wages that are already $15 or higher. After forecasting certain doom, one hotel advocate asked that the proposal be put on hold until a study could be completed, a tactic meant to delay, not enlighten. If the study concludes $15 would be beneficial, the hotels will dispute the findings. If the study shows $15 detrimental, the hotels will claim vindication. In the effort to defeat this measure, the hotel and business community spokemen (and they were all men) stopped just short of suggesting biblical plagues would result.

Speakers in favor of the proposal include Krystle Martin and Adrienne Jones, single mothers who were fired from their jobs shortly after they began agitating for fair wages and a union. Both were previously profiled on RI Future.

After the testimony last night the proposal will be voted on in committee next Thursday, and if it passes out of committee, it will be presented to the Providence City Council the following Thursday. Supporters are hoping for at least ten votes on the City Council, to thwart a possible veto by Mayor Angel Taveras. Supporters were holding signs reading “Angel Don’t Veto Working Women” to get ahead of this possibility. One would think that a man who wants to be governor would not consider voting against hard working hotel workers, 80% of whom are women, but this is an election year, so we can only hope that the Mayor will do the right thing and sign this bill into law upon passage.

Below you can see photos from the event, and pictures of all twenty-two speakers.

Fight for 15 001

Fight for 15 002

Fight for 15 003

Fight for 15 004

Fight for 15 005

Fight for 15 006

Fight for 15 008

Fight for 15 009

Fight for 15 010

Fight for 15 011

Here are photos and video of all 22 people who spoke in favor of the proposal. Not all of them were hotel workers. Business, labor and community leaders and members were represented.

Pro 15 01

Pro 15 02

Pro 15 03

Pro 15 04

Pro 15 05

Pro 15 06

Pro 15 07

Pro 15 08

Pro 15 09

Pro 15 10

Pro 15 11

Pro 15 12

Pro 15 13

Pro 15 14

Pro 15 15

Pro 15 16

Pro 15 17

Pro 15 18

Pro 15 19

Pro 15 20

Pro 15 21

Pro 15 22
Pre-City Council meeting

Pro $15 Speaker 01

Pro $15 Speaker 02

Pro $15 Speaker 03

Pro $15 Speaker 04

Pro $15 Speaker 05

Pro $15 Speaker 06

Pro $15 Speaker 07

Pro $15 Speaker 08

Pro $15 Speaker 09

Pro $15 Speaker 10

Pro $15 Speaker 11

Pro $15 Speaker 12

Pro $15 Speaker 13

Pro $15 Speaker 14

Pro $15 Speaker 15

Pro $15 Speaker 16

Pro $15 Speaker 17

Pro $15 Speaker 18

Pro $15 Speaker 19

Pro $15 Speaker 20

Pro $15 Speaker 21

Pro $15 Speaker 22

Post City Council meeting

For “balance,” here’s the five rich white guys who spoke against the proposal:

Anti 15 01

Anti 15 02

Anti 15 03

Anti 15 04

Anti 15 05

PVD City Council considers hotel minimum wage bill tonight


Deprecated: Function get_magic_quotes_gpc() is deprecated in /hermes/bosnacweb08/bosnacweb08bf/b1577/ipg.rifuturecom/RIFutureNew/wp-includes/formatting.php on line 4387

Deprecated: Function get_magic_quotes_gpc() is deprecated in /hermes/bosnacweb08/bosnacweb08bf/b1577/ipg.rifuturecom/RIFutureNew/wp-includes/formatting.php on line 4387

Hotel Workers Providence City Hall 012As the Procaccianti Group moves ahead with plans for a new hotel in downtown Providence, employees at another one of its downtown hotels will take their fight for fair wages to the City Council tonight. Employees and activists are requesting the Council pass a $15 an hour minimum wage ordinance for local hotel workers.

The Providence City Council will hold a public hearing to consider the idea today at 6:00 pm.

“I hope the Providence City Council does what is best for the average working mother like me and passes this ordinance,” said Santa Brito, a housekeeper at the Renaissance Providence hotel. “As elections come around, it’s a perfect opportunity to see who’s in the pocket of big business and who actually stands with regular working people of Providence, people from the neighborhoods, people who vote and who they are supposed to represent.”

Hotel employees at two Procaccianti Group-owned Providence hotels – the Renaissance and the Hilton – have been fighting to organize a union for years. The effort gained global attention in 2011, when local brass band What Cheer Brigade played backup to Joey DeFrancesco quitting his job at the Hilton. This year the employee strife has moved to the Renaissance, where activists say two employees have been fired for publicly protesting for higher wages.

Watch what Providence City Councilors are saying about the proposed minimum wage ordinance.


The Procaccianti Group, a property management company that owns and operates hotels globally, receives millions of dollars in tax breaks for the Renaissance hotel. Steve Ahlquist recently reported it lost its TAG accreditation for being LGBTQ friendly in 2013. The company would not comment on the matter. Today, the Providence Journal reports the Procaccianti Group would like to develop a third hotel in downtown.

“As a housekeeper in the Hilton Providence Hotel, I do grueling physical work and make only slightly above $9.00 per hour after eight years of service,” Hilton housekeeper Andrea Hernandez said. “On this paltry wage, I live paycheck to paycheck and can only afford the bare necessities. If I earned just $1.85 more per room cleaned, I could shop at local businesses and invest in my home. The whole city would benefit. There are hundreds of hardworking women like me in Providence hotels who deserve better. We hope the City Council will step up for working women in Providence.”

Hotel workers and their supporters will begin to gather in front of Providence City Hall today at 5:30. See the Facebook invite here.

Workers demand human rights at Hilton Providence


Deprecated: Function get_magic_quotes_gpc() is deprecated in /hermes/bosnacweb08/bosnacweb08bf/b1577/ipg.rifuturecom/RIFutureNew/wp-includes/formatting.php on line 4387

Deprecated: Function get_magic_quotes_gpc() is deprecated in /hermes/bosnacweb08/bosnacweb08bf/b1577/ipg.rifuturecom/RIFutureNew/wp-includes/formatting.php on line 4387

DSC_9785The first thing I noticed as I approached the Hilton Providence on Friday evening was the rented U-Haul truck parked conspicuously between the sidewalk where unionizing workers were staging their protest and the main entrance to the hotel.

The truck, placed so as to spare hotel management and guests the sight of underpaid and overworked employees advocating for fair wages and treatment, became a source of amusement and jokes among the protesters. When a gigantic 18-wheeler rumbled by emblazoned with a large “Teamsters” logo, chants of “We’ve got a bigger truck!” began, followed by laughter.

To highlight the abuse of workers rights alleged to take place at the hotel by the workers on the picket line, the protesters held a mock funeral for the United States Constitution. The document had a good run, said the protesters, only to be murdered by the Prociaccianti Group that owns and manages the hotel. Speaking in memory of the Constitution were Adrienne Jones, interviewed here at RI Future last Monday, and Krystle Martin, whose interview will be on this sight shortly, as well as many other workers and Providence Councilperson Carmen Castillo.

Since the unionization effort began, three union leaders have lost their jobs at the Hilton Providence and eight workers have been reprimanded, according to the organizers, so the Prociaccianti Group appears to be playing union busting hardball. Two of the fired workers, the aforementioned Jones and Martin, are single moms, leading some on the picket line to assert that the Hilton is targeting single mothers, who are more vulnerable economically. It’s hard to imagine more deplorable behavior.

Forming a union is an essential human right, and whatever efforts the hotel is undertaking to squelch the union is morally indefensible. The Prociaccianti Group is already bleeding business. The Unitarian Universalist General Assembly is bringing thousands of people to the Providence area this Summer, and they are not staying at the Hilton or the Renaissance (where workers are also batting for their right to unionize)  in response to the hotel’s treatment of its workers. More groups are sure to follow.

Meanwhile, local media, including the rapidly declining Providence Journal and local TV news continue to ignore the plight of workers fighting for their rights, leaving coverage of this developing story to the Brown Daily Herald and RI Future. Stories about real human suffering and economic exploitation are beneath their notice, it seems.

DSC_9511

DSC_9516

DSC_9529

DSC_9544

DSC_9564

DSC_9585

DSC_9590

DSC_9594

DSC_9597

DSC_9601

DSC_9631

DSC_9661

DSC_9664

DSC_9666

DSC_9671

DSC_9680

DSC_9686

DSC_9704

DSC_9718

DSC_9721

DSC_9725

DSC_9734

DSC_9738

DSC_9746

DSC_9750

DSC_9758

DSC_9791

DSC_9829

DSC_9876