A draft of the proposal has been obtained by RI Future. Because it is a draft and not covered by the Access to Public Records Act (APRA), Evan England, Mayor Elorza’s communications director, was unable to verify its authenticity. RI Future has independently confirmed that the draft proposal is the one currently under review.
The pilot program was presented at a meeting held Friday afternoon. Public Safety Commissioner Stephen Paré and Chief Hugh Clements were in attendance, as well as representatives from the City solicitor’s office and several community groups, including the ACLU and the NAACP. Those who attended the meeting were given a week to submit potential revisions to the draft regulations.
Two companies are providing free trials of their body cameras, Taser and Vievu. The timeline is vague, and has not been confirmed by the mayor’s office, but the PPD will have 5 weeks to test each company’s equipment. Once the equipment has been tested, the city will apply for a Federal grant to help pay for the cameras. England was able to say that he knows there are no planned announcements on body cameras over the next few weeks but at the meeting it was suggested that the program could potentially be unveiled as soon as early May.
It is unknown how much public input will be allowed into this process.
This story is developing and there will be more on this as we get it.
According to the draft proposal, which may be amended at any time, “It is the policy of the Providence Police Department to utilize body-worn camera equipment to record and document specific categories of law enforcement interactions with the public, and to institute parameters governing the viewing, storage and dissemination of the associated audiovisual recordings,” according to the draft policy.
Under the BWC Pilot Program the department is issuing BWCs to selected uniformed and investigative officers. “The BWC Pilot Program will be examined to determine whether or not BWCs contribute to officer safety, provide evidence for criminal prosecutions, help to resolve complaints made against personnel, and foster positive relationships with the community. BWCs are only intended to record that which an officer could potentially observe or hear using his/here own senses of sight and sound.”
The pilot program is considered a “work in progress” and it is possible the procedures outlined may be amended when the procedures run up against the “real world.”
Officers will be issued a particular BWC. Officers must continue to write their reports as before. They cannot write “refer to video” but must complete a thorough and detailed report.
Officers are required to activate their BWCs under the following circumstances:
If the officer does not activate the BWC under the above regulations, the officer must report the reason why to an immediate supervisor both verbally and in a written letter.
The BWCs should not be activated under the following circumstances:
Officers who make a prohibited recording must make a request for deletion to their immediate superior as soon as practicable.
Officers must inform, as soon as practicable, that they are recording by using the phrase, “I am advising you that our interaction is being recorded.” That said, permission from the subject is not required to record.
The BWC can not be stopped until the interaction is complete. Interruptions or premature terminations of recordings need to be reported and justified.
The recordings collected will be considered the property of the PPD. Members of the PPD may not copy, publish, share or disseminate any BWC audio or video without the permission of the Chief of Police or the Commissioner of Public Safety. Also, the recordings may not be edited, deleted or altered. They may not be stored on a cloud server or other media storage devices.
Video will be stored for 90 days, at which time it will be automatically deleted unless it is ordered to be archived.
It is a violation of the policy for recordings to be reviewed solely for the purposes of searching for instances of Department members committing violations of law or Department policy, unless reviews are related to a specific complaint, allegation or incident.
]]>The 30th annual “San Diego International Conference on Child and Family Maltreatment” is sponsored by the Chadwick Center at Rady Children’s Hospital, San Diego, and the University of California School of Medicine in San Diego. The conference’s focus is on multi-disciplinary best practices to prevent, investigate, treat and prosecute child and family maltreatment.
Col. Hugh Clements, Jr., Providence’s police chief, and Family Service of Rhode Island senior vice president Susan Erstling, PhD will present “Partnering With Police: Current Practices and Lessons Learned around Early Identification of Rhode Island Minors at High Risk for Sex Trafficking and Sexual Exploitation.”
Family Service of Rhode Island, a statewide non-profit, has partnered with the Providence Police for more than a decade on crime prevention and victim services. Family Service of Rhode Island also partners with the Rhode Island State Police and the East Providence Police on similar initiatives.
As part of the presentation, Family Service of Rhode Island has developed a video featuring Providence Police Detective Koren Garcia and Family Service of Rhode Island’s police liaison Carla Cuellar discussing how they work together with victims on issues relating to the legal system, emotional trauma, and medical care, and the role of Hasbro Children’s Hospital’s Child Safe Clinic.
https://youtu.be/zk5SADffDc8
“I urge everyone interested in sex trafficking issues, particularly persons in law enforcement and social work, to watch this video. It provides a real-world look at the day-to-day problems confronting victims and first providers,” said Dr. Erstling. She noted that January is “Human Trafficking Awareness Month.” Dr. Erstling is senior vice president of trauma, loss and children’s services at Family Service of Rhode Island, which is the regional site for the National Child Traumatic Stress Network.
“We are pleased to share the firsthand practical knowledge we have on helping traumatized victims with professionals from across the nation and beyond,” said Margaret Holland McDuff, CEO of Family Service of Rhode Island, who helped create the agency’s partnership with the Providence Police a decade ago.
Col. Clements and Dr. Erstling will be joined at the presentation by Amy Goldberg, MD, pediatric specialist at the Lawrence A. Aubin Child Protection Center, Hasbro Children’s Hospital. Dr. Goldberg will address the pediatric and medical aspects of child sex trafficking as well as collaborative strategies in conducting interviews, medical evaluations, and follow up care to reduce re-traumatization, avoid criminalization and to recognize the significant developmental and physical aspects of having been commercially exploited.
[From a press release]
]]>An internal affairs investigation found two of three Providence police officers guilty of violating department rules and regulations when they took John Prince‘s camera phone from him, according to Police chief Hugh Clements.
In September, 2014, Prince observed three police officers outside his home and used his phone to video the officers. They had detained two women and were asking “intimidating” questions while going through their handbags. The officers objected to being recorded, chased Prince inside his home, took his cellphone, deleted the video and threw the phone into the bushes, an egregious violation of Prince’s constitutionally guaranteed rights.
After San Lucas issued his finding, Colonel Hugh Clements, chief of the Providence Police, concurred and issued appropriate sanctions, he said in this letter. The supervising officer, Sgt. Roger Aspinal, was suspended for one day without pay, and must attend retraining. Officer Louis Gianfrancesco was not suspended but must attend retraining.
Prince and his lawyer, Shannah Kurland, will be holding a press conference Thursday at Providence City Hall to talk about the case. You can hear Prince tell his story in the video below.
]]>